Halloween · Conversation Game

30 Halloween Would You Rather Questions for Kids

Thirty impossible choices involving ghosts, candy, costumes, monsters and one extremely suspicious giant chicken.

Children in Halloween costumes playing together outdoors.

Would You Rather works because there is no correct answer. The explanation is the game. Ask everyone to choose a side, then defend it.

For a party, make kids move to opposite sides of the room to show their choice. For dinner, go around the table and let one person choose the next question.

30 Halloween choices

Question 1

Would you rather have a pet bat or a pet black cat?

Question 2

Would you rather live in a haunted house or sleep in a pumpkin patch?

Question 3

Would you rather be a friendly ghost or a silly vampire?

Question 4

Would you rather eat only candy corn or only caramel apples for a week?

Question 5

Would you rather have a witch’s broom or a vampire cape?

Question 6

Would you rather carve one giant pumpkin or twenty tiny pumpkins?

Question 7

Would you rather meet a talking skeleton or a talking spider?

Question 8

Would you rather have glow-in-the-dark hair or glow-in-the-dark shoes?

Question 9

Would you rather trick-or-treat in the rain or in the snow?

Question 10

Would you rather wear a robot costume made of boxes or a mummy costume made of fabric strips?

Question 11

Would you rather dance with zombies or sing with ghosts?

Question 12

Would you rather have a house full of bats or a yard full of frogs?

Question 13

Would you rather drink a bubbling purple potion or eat a green mystery cupcake?

Question 14

Would you rather be able to turn into a bat or disappear like a ghost?

Question 15

Would you rather find a secret room in your house or a mysterious door in your backyard?

Question 16

Would you rather have pumpkin-flavored toothpaste or candy-corn-flavored cereal?

Question 17

Would you rather hear a spooky noise in the attic or see glowing eyes outside the window?

Question 18

Would you rather go through a silly haunted house or a super-dark corn maze?

Question 19

Would you rather have a jack-o’-lantern for a head or skeleton hands for a day?

Question 20

Would you rather get ten giant candies or one hundred tiny candies?

Question 21

Would you rather be the person who tells the scary story or the person who turns off the lights?

Question 22

Would you rather wear your Halloween costume to school for a week or wear pajamas to a Halloween party?

Question 23

Would you rather ride in a hearse-shaped roller coaster or a broom-shaped airplane?

Question 24

Would you rather have a monster under your bed who tells jokes or a ghost in your closet who sings?

Question 25

Would you rather have orange skin or purple hair every October?

Question 26

Would you rather eat a chocolate spider or a gummy eyeball?

Question 27

Would you rather spend Halloween at a castle or on a pirate ship?

Question 28

Would you rather be chased by ten tiny zombies or one giant chicken?

Question 29

Would you rather only whisper “boo” or only speak in a monster voice all day?

Question 30

Would you rather invent a new Halloween candy or invent a new Halloween costume?